We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Justice, Home Affairs and Migration

Victims of Sexual Violence Civil Protection Orders Bill 2025: Committee Stage

Summary

Committee Stage focused on amendments to create civil protection orders for people convicted of specified sexual offences, including restrictions on contacting, following or approaching victims. The proposed changes also set criteria and duration for orders, provide victim and release notifications, and revise breach penalties and aggravating factors. Speakers broadly supported stronger protections, though Catherine Callaghan opposed reducing the maximum prison term for breaches from ten years to five; Report Stage remained to come.

Bill Victims of Sexual Violence Civil Protection Orders Bill 2025
Current

No. 38 of 2025 ›

An Leas-Chathaoirleach

I remind members to turn off their mobile phones or to switch them to silent mode. As the Cathaoirleach has tabled amendments to this Bill, I, as Leas-Chathaoirleach, will be chairing the meeting today. This meeting has been convened to consider Committee Stage of the Victims of Sexual Violence Civil Protection Orders Bill 2025. We will now proceed with consideration of the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Amendments Nos. 1 to 8, inclusive, are related. Amendments Nos. 2, 5 and 6 are consequential on amendment No. 4. Amendments Nos. 4 to 8, inclusive, are physical alternatives to amendment No. 3. Amendments Nos. 1 to 8, inclusive, may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 3, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:

“ “relevant person” means a victim in relation to whom an order under section 3 is sought or made.”.

I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach for officiating today. This is straightforward but important legislation. It is a small step we can take to support victims and survivors of sexual violence. The important thing to note is that this Bill comes directly from the experience and requests of survivors who themselves are determined to deliver change for others. At the outset, I want to express my sincere thanks to Sonya Stokes, Leona O'Callaghan and Shaneda Daly, who have been working with me on this Bill from the very start. They were introduced to me about 18 months ago by Senator Maria McCormack. They are powerful women who addressed the committed during the detailed scrutiny stage, alongside Paula Doyle. I thank her as well. She has informed us all, as Members, as to why this legislation matters. Sonya, Leona and Shaneda are in the Gallery today. I sincerely thank them for their support and testimony, which is the reason this Bill has had cross-party support up until this Stage.

I also acknowledge the organisations that have publicly expressed their support for the passage of this Bill, including Rape Crisis Ireland and Women's Aid. I listened to the points they made during the detailed scrutiny and tried where possible to reflect their particular issues in the amendments. I thank the Minister for allowing this Bill to proceed to Second Stage. I thank members of all parties who supported it on Second Stage. In particular, I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach and the members of this committee, who have facilitated it, engaged constructively during detailed scrutiny stage and expressed support, recognising that the Bill simply provides what is in place in relation to harassment legislation. At the same time, it allows that a court can decide to impose an order in the case of somebody affected by a crime of sexual violence, so as to restrain the person convicted of the offence from approaching the victim or survivor in the case. The provision currently exists in harassment legislation, in section 28 of the Criminal Justice (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2023, but it is not currently available to victims of sexual violence. This Bill seeks to fill that gap.

I want to make a couple of general points. Only a small fraction of people who are abused receive justice. The vast majority of cases of sexual, domestic or gender-based abuse do not even get reported. For those who do, only a small percentage ever experience and get justice. That has to change. The small percentage who do tell their story and are brave enough to report it, and who go through what is often a difficult and traumatic process and then ultimately secure a conviction, need to be heard. What they have told us is that while a conviction delivers a measure of justice, it does not bring an end to the challenges faced by victims and survivors. Many continue to carry a profound sense of fear and vulnerability. That is particularly the case when the offender nears release. Survivors have told us that the stress they feel can be overwhelming, knowing that the person responsible for the abuse may soon be back in their community. There is often a fear unwanted contact and the possibility of encountering their abuser in everyday settings, where they could be intimidated or harassed. Above all, they have asked to have clear protections in place so that they have some sense that they will not be subjected to further intimidation, contact or harassment.

I again thank the members of the committee for the consideration they have given the Bill during the detailed scrutiny stage. The amendments I bring forward today come as a result of the detailed scrutiny stage and in particular the advice we received from the Oireachtas legal services. I thank the officials within the Department who met with me to discuss the technical aspects of this Bill. Their input has been invaluable to the amendments I have brought forward.

I appreciate that Deputy Kelly has engaged with the Bill and has brought forward an amendment.

I suggest that the bulk of what is in his amendment is covered in the amendments that I have brought forward and I would appeal to him to allow my amendments to pass. If he sees that there remain any gaps within the legislation that are covered by his lengthy amendment, he might bring forward shorter amendments on Report Stage. I believe that is the most appropriate way of addressing this.

I will go through my amendments for the information of the members. Amendment No. 1 to section 2 addresses the concerns raised during the detailed scrutiny by clarifying who can benefit from a civil protection order, providing greater certainty and ensuring that the legislation is clear, effective and workable in practice.

Amendment No. 2 also addresses concerns raised during the detailed scrutiny. It clarifies the category of offender against whom a civil protection order may be made, again ensuring greater legal certainty and supporting the effective operation of this amendment.

Amendment No. 3 is in the name of Deputy Kelly. I again ask that the amendment be withdrawn at that stage because the bulk of the points are raised in subsequent stand-alone amendments that I have brought forward.

Amendment No. 4 addresses a number of issues raised during the detailed scrutiny as well as a recommendation from Women's Aid. It broadens the court's power to prohibit an offender from following or contacting a victim, allows multiple protective measures to be imposed through a single order and clarifies the preventative rather than punitive nature of the order. It also extends protection to any location frequented by the victim where the court considers it appropriate.

Amendment No. 5 is an insertion to the same section and responds to a number of concerns raised during the detailed scrutiny and by stakeholders. It introduces clearer criteria for the making of an order requiring the court to consider whether it is necessary and in the interests of justice. It provides greater legal certainty around the duration and commencement of orders, ensuring their operation is clear and proportionate. Importantly, it also reflects the recommendation of Rape Crisis Ireland by allowing victims and survivors to make written or oral submissions on the terms of any proposed order before it is made.

Amendment No. 6 seeks to address an important point raised by Rape Crisis Ireland during the detailed scrutiny. Rape Crisis Ireland highlighted the absence of any provision for victim notification prior to an offender's release and noted that prerelease notification is a basic safeguard widely recommended by victim support organisations. This amendment deals with that issue.

Amendment No. 7 addresses concerns raised during the detailed scrutiny by aligning the penalties for breaching a civil protection order with those that apply to comparable offences. Again, it ensures greater consistency, proportionality and coherence across the legislation.

The final amendment, amendment No. 8, addresses one specific issue that was identified during the detailed scrutiny regarding the aggravating factors that apply when a civil protection order is breached. It removes a provision that could not properly operate as an aggravating factor given that a prior conviction against a complainant is already a precondition for the order. It also responds to a recommendation from Women's Aid by recognising a current or former intimate relationship between the parties as an aggravating factor, bringing the Bill closer into line with established protections in domestic violence legislation.

I again thank the members for their consideration of those amendments, which I hope can be accepted.

Comment on this

As the amendments are grouped, I will speak in general terms. I acknowledge the work done by Deputy Carthy, Senator McCormack and Caoilfhionn Ní Dhonnabháin from the Deputy's office, who did a huge amount of work on them. Most of all, I thank the survivors Paula, Sonya, Shaneda and Leona. Three of them are here today. I thank them for sharing some of the most intimate and harrowing testimonies I have ever heard. As I have said before, it is difficult for me as a human being hearing those stories, and I can only imagine how difficult it is for them to have to share them over and over again. Even today in the audiovisual room, they shared their experiences to a group of people in the hope that this Bill will make other women's experiences a lot better than theirs, because more women will come after them. That is a really selfless act, and I thank them for that.

The Bill concerns cases where a person is convicted of sexual assault. It is about imposing a restraining order to protect the victim of that sexual assault, but it also relates to the post-custodial sentence stage. I have been talking about the Bill to people I know, such as my partner and others. They think this law is already in place, because it is common sense. People just think it is already in place, and the fact that it is not should show us that there is a hole in the legislation. It is a common-sense Bill, and so far we have had common sense on this committee in relation to it. I hope that this prevails and that we have cross-party agreement on this Bill such that it becomes law. I am speaking in support of the Bill and the amendments tabled by my colleague Deputy Carthy, but most importantly, I am speaking in support of the women here today and those who will come after them.

Comment on this

I will be brief. I commend Deputy Carthy on bringing forward such an important Bill. We will be supporting it to the fullest extent. I acknowledge the women who have had to come forward and place their trauma to the fore so that others do not have to suffer in the same way. They should not have had to demonstrate their remarkable courage and valour in the way they have. I hope this Bill makes things better for those who come after them.

Comment on this

Broadly speaking, I support any of the amendments that support and strengthen victim protection, victim notification and the recognition of aggregating factors. I support the principle as well behind the broader proposals, but if there are going to be major new statutory schemes, they should be brought forward by the Government following full legal conversations and advice from the Attorney General.

I do, however, oppose reducing the penalties for breaching protection orders from ten to five years. Those are my feelings on the Bill. I agree with Deputy Ward that in this committee in particular, we have a lot of cross-party support and agreement on many issues. That is a testament to how well we work together as a committee, and I want to see that continue.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Before I move to the amendment, I thank my colleagues and the Cathaoirleach for bringing the Bill forward. It is incumbent on us, as TDs, to always be reviewing the legislation that comes before us regarding the protection of citizens and in particular women. I have often said that we have never been in the back seat of the car over the last decades but that we have actually been outside the car. Any legislation that brings forward additional protections has to be warmly welcomed, and I look forward to seeing this going through the various stages in the committee.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 3, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:

“ “respondent” means a person who has been found guilty of an offence referred to in paragraphs (a) to (g) of subsection (1) of section 3 and against whom an order under section 3 is sought or made.”.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Deputy Kelly is not here.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 3, lines 27 to 28, to delete all words from and including “(1) Where” in line 27 down to and including line 28 and in page 4, to delete lines 1 to 10 and substitute the following:

“(1) Where a respondent is guilty of an offence under—

(a) the Criminal Law (Rape) Act 1981;

(b) the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act 1990;

(c) the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act 1998;

(d) the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2006;

(e) the Criminal Law (Human Trafficking) Act 2008;

(f) the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2017; or

(g) the common law offence of rape,

the court may, for the purpose of protecting the relevant person and without prejudice to any penalty imposed for the offence concerned, order that the respondent shall not, for such period as the court may specify, do one or more of the following—

(i) communicate by any means with or about the relevant person;

(ii) follow, observe, monitor, watch or otherwise keep the relevant person under surveillance, whether in person or by any electronic means;

(iii) approach within such distance as the court shall specify of the place of residence, education or employment or any other place frequented by the relevant person as the Court deems appropriate.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 4, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following:

“(2) In determining whether to make, vary or renew an order under subsection (1), and the terms, duration, scope and commencement date of any such order, the court shall have regard to—

(a) the need to protect the relevant person from intimidation, harassment, unwanted contact or harm by the respondent;

(b) the nature and circumstances of the offence concerned;

(c) the views of the relevant person, including any written or oral submissions made to the court;

(d) the effect of the proposed order on the rights and circumstances of the respondent; and

(e) all the circumstances of the case,

and shall not make an order unless satisfied that it is necessary and proportionate and that the interests of justice require the making of the order.

(3) An order made under subsection (1) shall specify the date on which it comes into effect and shall remain in force for such period as the court may specify.

(4) Where the respondent is serving a sentence of imprisonment, the court may direct that the order shall come into effect on the date of the respondent’s release from custody or on such later date as the court considers appropriate having regard to the circumstances of the case.

(5) The court may, on application by the relevant person, renew an order made under subsection (1) for one or more further periods, where it is satisfied that such renewal is necessary for the protection of the relevant person.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 4, between lines 19 and 20, to insert the following:

“(4) Where an order under subsection (1) is made, the relevant person shall be notified of—

(a) the making of the order;

(b) the date on which the order comes into effect;

(c) the period for which the order shall remain in force; and

(d) any variation, renewal, or expiry of the order.

(5) Where an order under subsection (1) is in force and the respondent is serving a term of imprisonment, the relevant person shall, where he or she wishes to receive such information, be notified of—

(a) the anticipated date of release of the respondent;

(b) any temporary release granted to the respondent;

(c) any decision which significantly alters the expected date of release; and

(d) the release of the respondent from custody.

(6) The Minister may make regulations prescribing the manner in which notifications under this section are to be provided.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:

In page 4, lines 27 and 28, to delete “a term of imprisonment not exceeding 10 years” and substitute “a term of imprisonment not exceeding 5 years”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:

In page 4, lines 30 to 32, to delete all words from and including “treat” in line 30 down to and including “complainant” where it secondly occurs in line 32 and substitute the following:

“treat as an aggravating factor—

(a) the use or threat of violence against the victim or a person connected with the victim,

(b) conduct intended to cause the victim fear, distress or intimidation, or

(c) the fact that the offence was committed by a person who is or was in an intimate relationship with the relevant person”.

Comment on this

Before the Leas-Chathaoirleach goes into the citation, I again thank the members. Obviously, we have one further Dáil Stage, which is Report Stage, which I am hoping we will secure time for very quickly. Then, I will be seeking to introduce the Bill into the Seanad and enact it at the beginning of the year. It was this time last year, in November, when the Bill passed Second Stage. The details we have had to go through in the time since were longer than I would have liked. It was my ambition that we would entirely pass this legislation this year. However, if we can ensure that the Bill is passed through all Stages of the Dáil and introduced in the Seanad at least this year, that will be a huge piece of work. It is a testimony because sometimes the political system can be lethargic. It can be very party political and there is an instinctive position from Government not to accept Private Members' motions or legislation. I think the reason a different approach has been taken in this instance is entirely down to the women who are in this Gallery because it has been their voices that have been heard above all else. That sends a very important message beyond this committee and beyond these Houses, because in respect of dealing with sexual, gender-based and domestic violence, above all, we need victims to know that if they tell their stories, they will be heard and believed, and when they point to deficiencies in the legislation, they will see action. The passage of this Bill is our small way of showing those things to be true and evident. I again thank all members for their support thus far.

Comment on this