Sustainable Energy Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–128 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 27 of 2001 ›
Amendment No. 2 is an alternative to amendment No. 1. Amendments Nos. 1 and 2 may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, line 13, after "Energy" to insert "Authority".
I welcome this Bill which is very important given the times in which we live. Much work has been done but much more needs to be done. We have tabled quite a number of amendments today in an effort to improve on the Bill and look forward to the debate on it.
We must treat this legislation and the body it sets up with respect. The body should, therefore, be called an authority; people will take more notice of its deliberations, suggestions and decisions if it is. The subject matter with which the Bill deals is so important, given the Kyoto Agreement and the difficulties we face, that we must give this new authority all the weight we can. I suggest that we do that by calling it the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. Let us give the body importance and weight by calling it an authority. That is the purpose of this amendment.
Comment on this
It is misleading to describe this legislation as a Sustainable Energy Bill when it concerns just one State agency. The short title should take that into account.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear the comments of colleagues on this very important Bill. It is obvious from the number of amendments being put forward with the intention of improving its provisions that the Bill has received much thought and consideration. I look forward to a healthy debate. I agree with what is being said about the authority and we will deal with that in later amendments.
Colleagues are seeking two different names for the Short Title. We had deliberations and the interim board had its own deliberations on the name of the new authority. We have had discussions with the Parliamentary Counsel and it was decided to settle on the title as set down. I do not think either of the amendments before us add anything to the Short Title of the Bill. Therefore, I am not disposed to go along with either of the proposed changes.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 3, line 15, before "Authority" to insert "the".
This is a technical amendment. The board is called the board and, for the sake of balance, the authority should be called the authority.
Comment on this
As Deputy Stanton said, this is a matter of drafting style. I am happy to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 10, 11, 66 and 67 are cognate to amendment No. 4 and they may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 3, line 15, to delete "body" and substitute "The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland".
These amendments relate to the title of the authority, as did amendment No. 1. In one part of the Bill, the authority is referred to as Sustainable Energy Ireland and in another part it is referred to as the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. These amendments are designed to ensure the authority has one title, the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. This has to do with the gravitas we attach to this legislation and the importance we give the agency that will be set up and known as "the Authority".
The Irish and English versions of the title are given. The amendments propose the deletion of the title "Sustainable Energy Ireland" and the insertion of "Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland". The thrust of these amendments is about giving the authority a certain amount of status and importance. Most other bodies we have set up are called an agency, an authority or a board. The title "Sustainable Energy Ireland" lacks a certain gravitas and punch. That is why we tabled these amendments. This is a technical matter. While changing the title will not make a major difference, it could make a difference in people's perception of the authority. We want to speak on this matter with authority and, therefore, the agency should be called an authority and should be known by one title, the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, not Sustainable Energy Ireland. If it is called Sustainable Energy Ireland, many people will question whether it is an authority, a board or something else. Let us call it an authority and be done with it.
Comment on this
This is a drafting matter. The definition as it stands is adequate for the purpose of the legislation. I am not prepared to accept a change of title of the new authority and, therefore, I cannot accept this amendment.
I accept the legal title of the authority is long and cumbersome. The Parliamentary Counsel advises that the name "Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland" is standard where a new State body or authority is being established. As other Deputies said, it is imperative that the word "Authority" appears in the section and it is there. It is advisable in such cases that a title with the word "Authority" contained in it is used and hence it is there.
On the other hand - this is an important point that I want to explain - the interim board I appointed in 2000 considered the issue of a suitable name for the new body and it was strong on this point in its recommendations. The board felt that a more modern business type name, which reflected the authority's functions, would be more appropriate. It favoured, and I agree with it, the title "Sustainable Energy Ireland". It requested that name. The interim board's views were guided by the need to have a name that was readily recognisable. Colleagues have spoken positively about the meritorious nature of this entity, this new authority. It is important that it should have a name that is recognisable, dynamic, modern and acceptable particularly to a younger regime, a younger audience. In that context, I appeal to colleagues not to press this amendment. The new body will be widely known as Sustainable Energy Ireland and can be more easily branded as such.
Comment on this
The reason it is proposed to change the title has been well outlined by Deputy Stanton. The title chosen has been selected for the sake of optics. As the Minister of State said, this is a drafting matter. The word "body" is inane, anaemic and rather weak. The proposed change of title has been made from the point of view of adding status to it. The title of bodies are shortened nowadays. For example, the title of FÁS has a natural rhythm. The change of title proposed, Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland would be shortened to SEAL. The change of title is proposed to give the authority added status and gravitas. I regret the Minister of State cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
It could give rise to confusion if the authority were to be known by two titles. For the sake of being trendy it will be called Sustainable Energy Ireland and for the sake of the legal situation it will be called the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. We are setting up a new body. The Environmental Protection Agency, the Industrial Development Authority and other such bodies are called what they are in effect. The establishment of a rail safety authority has also been mooted. The title "Sustainable Energy Ireland" does not mean anything, but if it were to be called the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland it would mean something to people.
With respect to the interim board, the decision on what this authority will be called will be made here. I heard what the Minister of State said, but I remind him that what is trendy today may not be trendy tomorrow. I am disappointed he will not accept this amendment. He might reconsider what we are trying to achieve and accept, as Deputy Higgins proposed, the deletion of the word "body" and its substitution by the words "Sustainable Energy Authority", as proposed in amendment No. 1. That is what amendment No. 4 seeks to do. Will the Minister of State agree to that?
Comment on this
Decisions will be made here, not by the interim board. I merely alluded to it to make it clear that a good deal of thought has gone into this over a long period and I am sure the Deputies, in putting forward the other view, have given it a good deal of thought and aspire to do what is in the best interests of the new authority. For instance, the title "Enterprise Ireland", has been readily accepted, as has the title "Horse-racing Ireland". Having given this matter much consideration, I wish to leave the wording as it stands.
Comment on this
I listened to what the Minister of State said. For the sake of clarity, acceptance of amendment No. 4 would not change anything except the substitution of the words "The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland" for the word "body". It would not change the name of the title of the authority. I am prepared to accept what the Minister of State said about that. I listened to him and he has made a good case and perhaps he will listen to us later when we will make equally strong cases on other matters.
Comment on this
The problem with the proposal to substitute the title "The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland" for the word "body" is that that title is not the full title, having regard to what I said earlier. The full title, Sustainable Energy Ireland - The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, is cumbersome and lengthy. For the purposes of its day to day operations, letter heading, business and functions, the authority will be known as Sustainable Energy Ireland.
Comment on this
There was a trend for a few years to find suitable titles for legislation and bodies. FÁS was mentioned by Deputy Higgins and Dúchas is the heritage body. Before we finalise this matter, it might be advisable to consider whether a short title such as Solas would reflect the business in which the board will be involved. I will not push the title that has been pushed here because in many respects it is not an apt name for it.
Comment on this
I oppose the amendment, which is similar to that put forward by other Deputies. It proposes to delete the words " "employee of the Authority" does not include the Chief Executive Officer;". This definition is not required in the Bill as there is no reference in it to an employee of the authority. The term used in this Bill is "a member of staff of the authority". In all sections where this appears it is clear that it either does not include or specifically excludes the chief executive. I am pleased on this occasion to be apparently ad idem with colleagues around the table.
Comment on this
We were concerned about what those words meant and why that definition was included. The Minister of State has agreed it was superfluous to needs and we are happy about that.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 6 and 7 form a composite proposal and they may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 3, line 20, to delete "as such".
This is a drafting matter. The deletion of the words "as such" would tidy up the wording. Those words are superfluous. The insertion after "section 3" of the words "to be the establishment day for the Authority for the purposes of this Act" would clarify the position.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 6 is a drafting matter and I am happy to go along with the Deputy's thinking on that. With regard to amendment No. 7, what it proposes is unnecessary. The wording of the amendment is cumbersome. The definition is clear as it is set out.
Comment on this
I go along with the Minister of State's thinking on that one and I will withdraw amendment No. 7.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 3, between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following:
" 'household' means the spouse, father, mother, grandfather, grandmother, stepfather, stepmother, son, daughter, stepson, stepdaughter, grandson, granddaughter, brother, sister, half brother or half sister;".
The term "household" is not defined in the Bill. The courts are grappling with the definition of a household. The term "household" was defined in other legislation such as the minimum wage legislation. I am trying to define what the term "household" means. Does it mean someone living in the house, a relation or someone who is visiting? It is incumbent on us to put clarity into the Bill with regard to the term "household". It appears elsewhere in the Bill but is not defined. I would be interested to hear what the Minister of State has to say on this. In defining the term "household", we attempted to include the close relatives of the people involved. That is what was done in the minimum wage legislation. This definition was found in that legislation. The courts are trying to define what is meant by a household and the term is important in the later sections. The term may be defined somewhere else and, if it is not, it should be.
Comment on this
I am not sure what Deputy Stanton means by including the word "spouse" in the definition of household. Whose spouse would that be?
Comment on this
There is a technical point which must be borne in mind and perhaps the courts will enlighten us on this in due course, as Deputy Stanton said. There is no recognition of homosexual marriage here. I presume we are talking about heterosexual households in this amendment.
Comment on this
There is a common understanding of what a household is and by trying to define it here we might leave out somebody who might, at a particular time, be part of a household. The definition in this amendment, for example, does not include partner or brother-in-law and it could be reasonably argued that the partner is part of a household, given what Deputy Stagg said.
The amendment relates to section 17. The provisions of that section are based on the Industrial Development (Enterprise Ireland) Act, 1998. The term "household" is not defined for the purposes of that Act and I am unaware that difficulties have arisen in Enterprise Ireland as a result. The existing staff of the Irish Energy Centre are staff of Enterprise Ireland and, therefore, currently operate under similar provisions. They appear to be comfortable with the existing provisions of the legislation.
We gave the amendment considerable thought since our colleagues considered it worthwhile to put it forward. However, it might create difficulties for the future. As Deputy Sargent pointed out, these are changing times and we could omit somebody who might in the future be deemed to be part of a household. In light of this, the parliamentary counsel advised against endeavouring to define "household" for the purposes of the Bill.
Comment on this
If feelings on it are strong, I will have no difficulty in reverting to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
That would be unwise because in defining the word, people will be omitted. It is common to have uncles and aunts living in households in the west of Ireland, for example. I do not know if that is true of the cities. If we attempt to define it, there will be all kinds of problems. It would be wiser just to use the term "household".
Comment on this
I would prefer to reach agreement on it today but I will not railroad the matter. If it is deemed advisable to have a further debate on it on Report Stage, so be it. However, I agree we might be confining ourselves in the future by defining the word at this time.
Comment on this
I know what the Minister means but the amendment relates specifically to section 17 of the Bill which deals with disclosure of interests. Subsection 17(2)(a) refers to “he or she or any member of his or her household, or any nominee of such person . . . ” while (b) states “he or she or any member of his or her household is in partnership with . . . ” While difficulties might not have arisen, it is conceivable that at some stage it will be necessary to define what is meant by “household”. In other words, where is the line drawn in relation to what is encompassed by the term? We are not pressing the point but the issue could arise at some stage. The fact that it has not arisen until now does not mean it cannot arise.
Comment on this
As Deputy Sargent pointed out, this is currently being debated in the courts in another context. It is causing difficulties. We are providing in the Bill for the disclosure of interests, which is a relatively new concept. In fairness, therefore, we should not use a catch-all word such as "household" without trying to define it. It has a wide meaning. It could include an aunt, uncle, cousin, someone living in the house or somebody visiting. It could also include a lodger. Is there a definition of household anywhere which could be used? The matter is before a court at the moment in a different context so it is not a theoretical, abstract problem. It is a real problem. The Minister should seek further advice on it and revert to it on Report Stage.
For the sake of clarity, the word "partner" could be included. I have no problem with that. Father, mother, grandfather and so forth constitute close relatives. Does household include one's brother who does not live in one's house? There is a difference between family and household and I understand that that definitions in the Constitution of family and household are not compatible.
This is not an abstract issue. It is real and is currently causing difficulty in the courts. It is our responsibility to have clarity in legislation, not to create a situation where the matter will be sent to the courts to deal with because we cannot or will not do so. It is our job to provide clear definitions. Let us put parameters and a definition on the term, if we can. I will not press the amendment at present but I urge the Minister to consult again with the Attorney General and the other legal eagles about it. It is already causing a problem.
Comment on this
I prefer to leave it at that. We have given the matter a good airing. Confining ourselves to a definition is fraught with danger but I am happy to consult further on it, particularly with the parliamentary counsel. We can discuss it again on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 9 and 27 form a composite proposal and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 3, between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following:
" 'the lean economy' means an economy independent of finite and increasingly scarce imported fossil fuels and tailored to maximise energy conservation and rely primarily on renewable energy sources;".
It was mentioned earlier that the Bill focuses very much on one sector, electricity. It is seen as an important part of what sustainable energy could be. Unfortunately, what we are in danger of doing is creating a body that will be little more than a press office to announce or press for measures but which will ultimately not be able to or expected to outline an overall economic vision of a sustainable society where sustainable energy is the important component.
I am arguing for the concept of the lean economy to be inserted as a definition. My suggested definition is that it means "an economy independent of finite and increasingly scarce imported fossil fuels and tailored to maximise energy conservation and rely primarily on renewable energy sources". I hope the Minister will consider the amendment favourably. It would mean inserting in the Bill an indication that this new expanded body has the responsibility to outline ways for society to be truly sustainable. It is the nearest we have come to having such a body.
The amendment is necessary not just because of the Kyoto obligations, which are only the beginning of a long process of negotiations that will probably become more onerous for us even though we do not appear to be capable of living up to the existing obligations, minimal as they may be in the international context. It is also not just because the insurance companies are increasingly insisting that storm damage and other climate change related damages will increase the cost of insurance premia for everybody. It is because I am receiving more and more scientific evidence from people such as Dr. David Fleming, who gave a lecture called The Lean Economy in Trinity College last October, that there is a need to not just try to cut down on energy but also articulate a way in which we can live in the future when the finite resources on which we are absolutely dependent, which is similar to the way many drug addicts depend on heroin, will not be available to us. The concept should be included in the Bill so that the sustainable energy authority can articulate a vision of our society. Many more things could be said about this subject. That is why I tabled the amendment.
Comment on this
The thrust of these amendments is already covered by the existing functions of the new authority. The authority is to promote and assist, among other things, energy efficiency and renewables. It would not add anything to the Bill to insert the concept of a lean economy. The proposed amendment to section 6 could involve the authority promoting such concepts outside Ireland, which would take the remit of the authority beyond what is envisaged in the Bill. Ireland will continue to vigorously promote renewables at all fora available to us, including the United Nations. However, it will not be tied into the important functions of the authority. I reject the amendments.
Comment on this
I am disappointed the Minister of State is not prepared to accept the amendment and has emphatically rejected it. As regards his contention that amendment No. 27 would involve areas outside Ireland, the energy we use comes primarily from outside Ireland. We must recognise that we cannot live in isolation from the energy markets outside the country. We could become pedantic about it and say the wind is not Irish, but that is probably going too far. We must get away from the minimalist approach and from talking about efficiency and promoting renewables - the Minister of State is using that language. I am not being dramatic, but it is similar to speaking at a health committee about the difficulties of drug addiction. We have become reliant and dependent. It is time the Government gave leadership and articulated what will happen in the future. We are not talking about an accident at Sellafield and what might happen, but about what will happen. It will become more difficult to acquire oil, coal and fossil fuel energy supplies. The Minister of State may say that is a matter for another generation or Government. I ask him to consider future generations in the Bill. We are not doing that by adopting a minimalist approach.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Sargent. The Bill goes a certain distance, but the amendment goes further. It defines a target for the future and seeks to ensure that we strive to be independent of fossil fuels. We should lead by example in Europe. The Minister of State said our wind and wave energy are unparalleled in Europe. We have totally untapped solar energy. Digesters are rarely used in this country. Fossil fuels are finite and they will run out. The Kinsale field has virtually run out. We are lucky to have discovered the new gas field in the Corrib, but that will not last forever. We must have a goal to become independent of such scarce resources as much as we can. It would be nice to be totally independent of them, but I do not know if that will happen. The amendment sets out that goal. I strongly support my colleague and I urge the Minister of State to reconsider his position. We should strive for the ideal. I am disappointed and surprised the Minister of State emphatically rejected it given that he has consistently said he is in favour of renewable energies and that he wants to move away from fossil fuels. The Minister of State should include it in the Bill.
Comment on this
I assure everyone concerned that the Government is not adopting a minimalist approach in terms of the Bill or this issue. It is distressing to hear Deputy Sargent——
Comment on this
We must ensure the Deputy adopts a different perspective. It is distressing to hear the Deputy speak about the new authority as being nothing more than a press office. The Irish Energy Centre has proven it is far from being a press office. I expect great things from it when it is put on a statutory basis and I know it will deliver. As regards external matters, there is an implication in amendment No. 27, which states "to promote the concept and development of lean economies, especially in Ireland", that the authority will work abroad.
Comment on this
Its work is important and ongoing. The Irish Energy Centre work programme is well known. It knows what it must tackle. Much of it has been outlined in the Green Paper and it has been well received. The future work programme will include major concentration on research and development, such as wave energy technology with which I am enamoured. We were advised the technology must be developed further. Such research and development will be spearheaded by the new authority. I reject the use of the word "minimalist". I am sure we can improve the legislation, but these amendments will not add anything to it.
Comment on this
I will not press the amendment because the Minister of State has set his face against it. However, I reserve the right to come back to it on Report Stage. I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 12:
In page 4, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Freedom of Information Act, 1977 shall apply to the Authority.".
The strange omission of the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act, 1997, glaringly stands out in this legislation. I am seeking to insert a new section 5, as follows, "5.-The Freedom of Information Act 1977 shall apply to the Authority." One wonders why that is not included already.
In the Seanad debate it was mentioned that by virtue of the fact that the Irish Energy Centre has been subject to the Freedom of Information Act since January 2001, one must ask why this new authority will not similarly come under the aegis of the Act. I know that the Irish Energy Centre comes under its aegis because it is an adjunct of Enterprise Ireland. Therefore, we are seeking to have the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act applied to this authority as it applies to others, including the Irish Energy Centre.
Comment on this
My colleague, Senator Ryan, tabled this amendment in the Seanad. I have tabled it here to copperfasten what the Minister had to say so that it will be on the record here as well. In the Seanad debate the Minister stated: "I will ensure that the new authority is included in the schedule for the Freedom of Information Act as soon as possible after the establishment of the new authority." Pressed further, the Minister said: "That will be done expeditiously." I want to copperfasten that here and if I get that commitment from the Minister I will be happy enough.
Comment on this
As Deputies have said, in response to a similar amendment in the Seanad I gave a commitment to include the authority under the Freedom of Information Act. The Irish Energy Centre is currently subject to that Act by virtue of being a division of Enterprise Ireland. I am anxious, as are our colleagues here, that in its transition to an independent statutory body, it will continue to be subject to the Act. The proposed amendment is based on recent legislation such as the Mental Health Act, 2001. I am advised, however, that the more appropriate way to achieve the end, with which I agree and to which I am committed, is to amend the Third Schedule to the Freedom of Information Act. On Report Stage I propose to bring forward an amendment to do that. In that way I believe I will meet the objective articulated by colleagues today.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 4, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Authority shall, subject to the provisions of the Act, be independent in the exercise of its functions.".
This is a technical amendment which seems to be a standard provision in other legislation. It copperfastens the provision that the authority would be subject to the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act and would be independent in the exercise of its functions. The amendment would make clear that it is a statutory authority which is independent in its workings, subject to the Act. This provision appears in many Acts. It is important for us to signal to the authority that it is independent in the exercise of its functions.
Comment on this
I have a difficulty with this because I am worried about quangos. In stating that it is independent, I want to know of whom it is independent. Does that mean it is independent of the democratically elected Oireachtas? If so, I would require much clarity before supporting it. I am worried that we are transferring authority from the Oireachtas to outside non-responsible authorities. I am worried because the term "independent" usually means that those who are elected cannot give them instructions. If that is the case, I would not agree with it.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Stagg has read through the amendments and has noted that, like himself, I have tabled another amendment later seeking that this authority should be accountable to the Dáil through the Minister by way of parliamentary questions for information purposes. The Minister for Public Enterprise, Deputy O'Rourke, has told us there are moves afoot to do so for all the so-called quangos that Deputy Stagg mentioned. At the same time, bodies such as this authority should be independent and should go about their business independent of political interference, including ministerial interference, subject to the provisions of the Act. The Act outlines certain roles for Ministers, Oireachtas committees and Deputies by way of parliamentary questions. The authority should be statutorily independent in order to go about its business without interference. This provision is included in many other Acts.
Comment on this
The authority is an independent legal entity bound by the provisions of the Act. As such, I consider this amendment is superfluous and I cannot accept it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 4, subsection (1), between lines 12 and 13, to insert the following:
"(a) to provide a working definition of sustainable energy and to update the definition on a regular basis having regard to developments in available technology;”.
This matter was discussed at great length in the Seanad. I have the advantage of knowing what the Minister might say in response to it here because I have the Official Report in front of me. There was a learned discussion on the matter between the Minister and Senator Ryan. I thought the debate was inconclusive despite its length and learned nature. People are interested in maximising renewable sustainable energy production and what we are doing here, in putting in place the infrastructure for that, is a positive step in that direction. We should state clearly, however, what energy sources we are talking about. I am thinking of wind, solar and wave energy and I am sure no one will contradict me on that. Some people, however, may say "Yes" or "No" to combined heat and power, so we need to know what we are talking about. That is essential.
Some people accept turf as an energy source while others reject it. Turf generally comes under the barrier from the EU's point of view and we have succeeded in doing that because of its special national interest. Many others would argue that turf should be excluded from renewables and that, perhaps, there should be a ban on its use. Being from the Bord na Móna constituency of Kildare I am not making that argument today, but when it is made I understand it. We should specify what we are talking about. I am aware what the Minister said in the Green Paper so I do not require a long answer from him, but we should be specific.
Comment on this
I support Deputy Stagg's amendment. Not only should we be defining the energy there, but part of the difficulty in only having a definition is that it begs the wider question of how one uses that. It is not so much the energy, it is the technology that is involved in making that energy which is what we are really talking about. In many ways, I take issue with the European Union concerning its own belief in incineration, for example, which it likes to call energy recovery. If one were to define the efficiency of energy recovery in such a technology, one would find it is less of an energy recovery than, for example, the proper reuse of the materials which would save production energy in the first place. Let us talk about definitions here rather than simply throw around terms which lead to a false sense of security about a major shift in thinking when it is simply a fashion parade of terminology rather than a real change. I support this because we need definitions to know what we are talking about.
Comment on this
This is a very good amendment. We are setting up the sustainable energy authority and yet it is not defined in the Bill. That is fair enough but when the authority is up and running there should be a clear definition of what it is about. That should be included as part of its function. There is a provision in this amendment to up date the definition on a regular basis as other forms of energy may become available at some stage. Perhaps we will discover some form of geo-thermal energy in Wicklow. This amendment would not take from the Bill. As far as the functions of the authority are concerned, it is a very welcome amendment. It would give clarity to the definition of sustainable energy and provide a mechanism to up date it on a regular basis. I compliment Deputy Stagg on tabling the amendment and press the Minister of State to accept it so we can move on.
Comment on this
I will endeavour to accede to Deputy Stagg's request for a short answer. As regards his reference to the Green Paper, we endeavoured to set down how Ireland would progress towards meeting its energy requirements in an environmentally and economically sustainable way having regard to economic growth and security of supply objectives. "Sustainability" is defined in the Green Paper as ensuring the needs of present generations can be met without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs. I set out in the Green Paper that a sustainable energy policy should do a number of things on which I will not, at Deputy Stagg's request, elaborate.
I am, however, satisfied that the functions of the authority, as set out in section 6, encapsulate all those requirements. I do not agree the sustainability concept needs constant redefining. Those of us who attend different fora throughout the world hear new and very flowery definitions and re-definitions of sustainability and sustainable energy but we know what we are talking about and what we want to achieve. It depends primarily on using best available technology and best practise to achieve that sustainable goal. In all those circumstances, I do not see it as a function of this new authority to define "sustainability". Its role is to ensure this country utilises best practise in all its energy supply and use to limit the harmful effects of energy use. That is my position on it.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister of State to reconsider this. We are not asking the Minister of State to define sustainable energy now, but it needs to be defined on an ongoing basis because the situation is changing and new sustainable energies and technologies are becoming available. Am I wrong in suggesting to the Minister of State that his officials might be afraid their curriculum vitae might be handed over to the new authority and that would take from their power within the system to limit and determine what the authority might do? If one allows the authority to define sustainable energy, it would have a very clear role in saying what it is about. Is that the reason this is being resisted? The reasons the Minister of State has given are not sustainable, if he does not mind me using the word in a different context, and the arguments he has made are like Galileo’s dialogue where one knows very well what one is saying is not sustainable in itself. It is very good to have this debate because this is at the core of the issue. Do the officials want to hold on to the authority to define this on a day to day basis as cases come up? No one will know the definition until they say what it is. Will we now say we have a new authority and that we should let it write its curriculum vitae? It would be much better to give the new authority that authority, particularly with the controls we had previously.
Comment on this
Deputy Stagg has spoken like a true and very worthy incumbent of this office over a period of time. In that context, he will know the incumbent officials would not dream of behaving in the way or adhering to what——
Comment on this
——he is suggesting. I am tempted to have another look at this, if I may, and talk to the Deputy about it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 4, subsection (1)(a), line 13, to delete “and economically”.
In a way section 6 is the core of the Bill in that it defines what the authority will do. We should give it a lot of attention and we have done that by putting forward many amendments, although quite a number of them have been ruled out of order. That is, however, another story. The amendment proposes to examine section 6(1)(a) and to rewrite it to state that one of the functions of the authority should be to promote and assist environmentally sustainable production, supply and use of energy.
I was a little concerned when I saw the words "environmentally and economically sustainable production" because when one ties economics into sustainable production, it could limit what could be done. Does it mean that if a certain form of energy production is not economic, or economically sustainable, as stated here, the authority will have no function in promoting, assisting and supporting it? Who will define what will be economically sustainable? A lot of economically sustainable technologies would be made that way by way of Government action in terms of revenues, price structures of energies and so on. The Portuguese, for instance, are making it economically viable for wave energy to be developed whereas so far we are not paying real premium for green energy.
What I am trying to do is to break the link between environmentally sustainable production and economically sustainable production. If something is not economically sustainable - if it does not pay its way - does that mean we do not promote it? There are many forms of green energy - for want of a better term - which are probably not economically sustainable in present circumstances and may never be unless we break the link here. Further on, we have tried to incorporate the economics of it and to state that the authority should be aware of it and should try, as far as possible, to consider economics as well. We should be careful about tying it in here as far as the functions are concerned.
Comment on this
This is an interesting and correct amendment. The words "and economically" should be deleted because to determine what is meant by economical is similar to walking a minefield. The Minister of State will be aware from the Green Paper and the many world-wide fora to which he has referred that the internal costs of the energy currently forming the bulk of our energy supply are far greater than the price we pay, especially if the downstream clean up costs and the difficulties of replacing exhausted resources are taken into consideration.
On what criteria are the economic costs of fuel decided? Is it the short-term economic approach currently in vogue or longer-term economic considerations, which a sustainable energy approach requires us to take? The Minister of State will be aware of the cost of the proposed Arklow wind farm, which I hope will be a long-term investment with a long-term payback. It represents a very different type of economics to the building of peat fire stations.
According to the book, Creating Sustainable Cities, published in 1999, solar energy is approximately eight times more expensive than conventional forms of energy but it is expected to be competitive as early as 2010 as technology develops and markets grow. Some countries have already decided to proceed with it on this basis. The authority should look ahead and not be constrained by the current economic straightjacket, which, on the face of it would consider this kind of approach to be a waste of money and would call for an adherence to existing energy sources, such as peat and coal. In view of this, the insistence on economy of means in today’s prices is wrong, especially when a given energy source could be very economical in the future.
Comment on this
There is a need to retain the words "and economically" in this context. The authority must have regard to the cost element of the equation. Programmes, technologies and any other measures that are excessively costly could have negative impacts where they are least wanted. For example, they could have an impact on fuel prices for the poor and elderly or on industrial competitiveness. The authority must give consideration to cost issues. Given the pace of developments, measures that are not economical today may be within a relatively short period of time. However, to remove from the authority a provision obliging it to take account of the economics of projects would be to irresponsibly give it a carte blanche to act.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said the authority must be exciting and innovative, yet he is imposing economic constraints on it which will defeat that. It is as if he does not want it to experiment. The first function of the authority is to promote and assist, environmentally and economically, sustainable production, supply and use of energy. Does this mean it cannot promote and assist the production, supply and use of a production of a form of energy that is not economically sustainable today and that it could not, for example, consider the use of geo-thermal sources of energy or heat transfer machines because they are not economically sustainable?
There is a need to address this. We can agree that the first function of the authority should be to promote and assist environmentally sustainable production and supply of energy. A later provision should then require it to take note of economic factors without constraining it to the extent that what it promotes must be currently economically sustainable. By breaking the link with the economic requirement the authority could be free to do much more.
Comment on this
This provision requires more detailed consideration. Economic factors are vital because society could not function properly without them. However, there is a need to distinguish between short-term and long-term economics. One of the functions of the authority should be to promote the economic evaluation of energy technologies, having regard to short-term and long-term considerations. Technology projects could be piloted with a view to testing their feasibility. This would allow for their development and expansion when market conditions were right. While economic conditions must be a factor, the function of the authority should be to evaluate the economic viability of the schemes. It should not be constrained to only promoting current economic sustainable production. Wedo not want short-term considerations to dominate.
Comment on this
We could debate this indefinitely but we must take account of the real world. The national development plan will ensure the authority will have substantial funding at its disposal which I have no doubt subsequent Governments will maintain. However, it would be irresponsible to remove a provision requiring the authority to take cognisance of economic factors when evaluating projects. Section 6(1)(b) requires it to promote and assist energy efficiency and renewable sources of energy. I am sure the board and its management will adhere to those functions and responsibilities and will demand, and be supported in fora such as this and in the Oireachtas, the resources necessary to proceed with the functions clearly set out in the legislation. I do not believe carte blanche is a realistic way to proceed.
Comment on this
I presume the Minister of State intends there will be value for money in the energy that will be produced arising from the activities of the authority. That is the reason for including the word "economically". I presume that would not prevent research into modes of energy generation that are currently not economical, for example, wave energy. The technology it will require means it is not yet economical. I assume the Minister of State is arguing for value for money.
Comment on this
It is not that the funding for particular jobs would be cut or shortened but the end product that would be promoted would have a value for money audit carried out on it.
Comment on this
The Minister referred to section 6(1)(c) which states, "to promote and assist the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and transboundary air pollutants associated with the production, supply and use of energy". Does that mean in the case of Moneypoint, for example, where people are already claiming the stacks emit substantial air pollutants and transboundary air pollutants, this new authority could close that plant? Is that the economic aspect the Minister of State has in mind? Where are the economics in that case?
Comment on this
The section is clear. It refers to the production, supply and use of energy and that is what is happening in Moneypoint.
Comment on this
Yes, but it refers to the authority's function of promoting and assisting sustainable production, supply and use of energy. I could not put it better than Deputy Stagg put it earlier. Basically, the concept of value for money must be part of any real world situation.
Comment on this
One can argue about the value for money with regard to the emission of pollutants from Moneypoint. Would it be better to pay for more expensive electricity so people would have better health or does the cheaper cost of production allow us to export many more goods? Is that the economic choice one makes? The amendment, in seeking to analyse it, hits the point. I cannot see the sense in paragraph (c). Why refer to transboundary air pollutants associated with the production, supply and use of energy if the Minister of State is not referring to Moneypoint and other facilities?
Comment on this
I do not know what point the Deputy is making. He refers to the requirement to promote and assist the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and transboundary air pollutants in the new authority's functions and refers to that function in relation to facilities such as Moneypoint. However, the authority is not in the business of making decisions in relation to Moneypoint. It is there to promote and assist with a view to achieving that which is aspired to in this legislation.
Comment on this
I wish to refer again to the environmental tag. The section states that the functions of the authority shall be "to promote and assist environmentally and economically sustainable production". There is no "or", "if" or "maybe". It is the "environmentally and economically sustainable production, supply and use of energy". It has to be economically sustainable. What does economically sustainable mean? In my opinion, it means that it pays its way and is profitable. Under the section it must be environmentally and economically sustainable.
We are trying to break the link. We areseeking the removal of the phrase "and economically" in that subsection. I intended to insert it further down in the section but my amendment was ruled out of order because of the silly rule under which the Opposition cannot put forward amendments that might impose a cost on the Exchequer. I attempted to insert the phrase further down in the section and link it to conservational efficiency and the economic use of energy. Perhaps the Minister of State would consider doing that.
I am anxious to break the link between environmental and economical. Our focus must be environmental and that must stand out. We are suggesting that the authority promote and assist the environmentally sustainable production, supply and use of energy. We are not suggesting the economic aspects be ignored because they must be taken into account. However, we must break the link in this paragraph between the two. The Minister of State is linking them. English is English and the paragraph reads "to promote and assist environmentally and economically sustainable production". Let us break the link between the two. There is no need to ignore it; it can be inserted further down in the section. The Minister of State has the power to do it.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy suggesting this Government or, more pertinently, this authority proceeds to promote and assist non-viable or non-economical projects and technologies?
Comment on this
What is non-economical today may well be economical tomorrow. That is the point. Wave energy at present may not be economical but if it were promoted, developed and assisted, one could reach a stage where it could become economical. This is the point of the legislation. The Minister of State should break the link; he should be courageous on this issue and make a decision.
Comment on this
I was assisting the Minister of State in my point regarding Moneypoint. The ESB tells us it is uneconomical to install filters in the stack at Moneypoint. The new authority is being given the responsibility to promote and assist in the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and transboundary air pollutants. Will the ESB still not say, even if the capital is available, that it is uneconomical? That is what it has been saying for years.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the existing power stations are deemed to be uneconomical in comparison with the two new power stations?
Comment on this
I am not talking about Moneypoint but about the two new peat stations. Clearance had to be secured from Europe for a public service obligation and subsidy. If we are serious about the objectives in the Bill, that linkage must be broken and if it means subsidisation, so be it. It is subsidisation in the interests of the environment. It is a short-term consideration from the point of view of achieving environmental objectives.
Comment on this
Most green energy is uneconomic at present. We must work to ensure that its production becomes economically viable. According to the Bill, the authority will not be able to promote and assist green energy production. It must, therefore, be environmentally and economically sustainable.
Comment on this
What is missing among the authority's functions is a mechanism to allow it to evaluate the long and short-term economic dimensions and the internal and external costs of sustainable energy technology. If, instead of just considering current costs, we took account of internal costs, we could present the argument in a way which would ensure the case relating to the economic consideration would be won. The Bill does not deal adequately with the economics of sustainable energy. Perhaps such a function could be conferred on the authority because it might help everyone involved.
Comment on this
I do not believe we are at odds on this issue, we are all aspiring towards reaching the same goal. Perhaps matters have not been explained in the way they ought to have been. Section 6(1)(b) states that one of the functions of the authority shall be “to promote and assist energy efficiency and renewable sources of energy”. In my opinion, this covers what the Deputies are seeking to achieve in their amendment and, rightly so, there is no reference to economic constraints. Section 6(1)(a) states that another of the authority’s functions shall be “to promote and assist environmentally and economically sustainable production, supply and use of energy”. A technology of which I and other Members are enamoured is CHP - combined heat and power - which is economically and environmentally sustainable. Section 6(1)(a) will allow the authority to “promote and assist” the production of CHP. I am sure everyone present would want to facilitate the authority in doing just that. The other renewable sources of energy - wind energy, wave energy, et al - are covered under section 6(1)(b). In my opinion, therefore, we are at cross-purposes in our discussion on this matter.
Comment on this
I do not want to reiterate what has already been stated but the economic aspects of this issue are extremely important and it is vital that we get matters right. I wish to draw the Minister of State's attention to amendment No. 18, which has been ruled out of order. Perhaps he might consider tabling a similar amendment that would meet everyone's requirements by breaking the link with the need for environmentally sustainable production while, at the same time, allowing the authority to promote the economical use of energy. If the Minister of State took this course, we might be able to proceed because all eventualities would be covered.
Comment on this
What Deputy Stanton is suggesting is that perhaps the Minister of State might give consideration to the content of amendment No. 18 in the context of the amendment under discussion.
Comment on this
The danger with leaving such matters until Report Stage is that a guillotine is usually applied which means we do not have a further opportunity to state our case. This happened in respect of a number of previous Bills. I do not believe we have any choice but to move on because the Minister of State is opposing the amendment. I ask him to reconsider the matter and, perhaps, try to reach some compromise in respect of it. In the interests of——
Comment on this
I apologise for interrupting, but I believe I am singing the same song as the Deputy and others present in respect of this issue. He may have grasped the wrong end of the stick with regard to what I have stated. We will look at the amendment in the context of what has been proposed.
Comment on this
It is worth pointing out that amendments Nos. 16 to 20, inclusive, which were ruled out of order, involve potential charges on the Revenue and only the Government can table amendments of this nature.
Comment on this
It is for that reason that we are asking the Minister of State to consider tabling an amendment similar to No. 18 for Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 16 to 20, inclusive, are ruled out of order as they involve potential charges on the Revenue.
Comment on this
Are Deputies allowed to speak to the amendments even though they have been ruled out of order?
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 21, 26 and 31 are related and may be taken together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 4, subsection (1), between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following:
"(e) to propose legislative and fiscal measures to achieve the objectives stipulated in the foregoing subparagraphs of this subsection;
(f) to prepared and publish annual reports on the relative performance of the State and each of the other Member States of the European Union relating to sustainable energy objectives;”.
This amendment was dealt with in the Seanad, where it was tabled by my colleague, Senator Brendan Ryan. It seeks to provide the authority with an additional purpose. We are not suggesting the authority should supplant the Oireachtas by being allowed to initiate legislation. However, the existing section 6(1)(f) states that it shall be the function of the authority to “provide advice, information and guidance . . . to the Minister and such other Ministers or bodies as the Minister may direct”. In that context, our amendment states that it should be able to propose to the Minister, or any other Minister, legislative and fiscal measures to achieve the objectives already stipulated in the section. The authority will probably do so in any event but the amendment would strengthen its hand by giving it an actual role in terms of advising the Minister in respect of legislation.
The second part of the amendment relates to accountability and the need to make information available if it is collected. If the authority collects specific comparative information with regard to other member states, we will be in a position to measure the progress we are making and apply a benchmark. That is the essence of the argument.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 26, which is similar to the second part of Deputy Stagg's amendment, states that it should be a function of the authority to "prepare and publish reports on the relative performance of the State in terms of achieving energy efficiency and sustainable energy measures by comparison with other EU Member States." It is vital that there should be a regular assessment of Ireland's performance in this area and that of the authority we are establishing vis-à-vis its counterparts in other countries.
The functions outlined in section 6(1)(a), (b) and (c), namely, “to promote and assist environmentally and economically sustainable production, supply and use of energy . . . to promote and assist energy efficiency and renewable sources of energy . . . to promote and assist the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and transboundary air pollutants associated with the production, supply and use of energy”, and those in paragraphs (d), (e) and (f), are laudable. However, we should be aware of what is happening in other countries. We should be in a position to carry out a regular comparison of Ireland’s performance and that of the new authority vis-à-vis other countries. That is what the amendment seeks to do.
Comment on this
It is interesting that Fine Gael, the Labour Party and the Green Party have all tabled amendments. While they are not the same, they identify a need for the authority to make known its interest in introducing measures and making changes to fiscal policy to assist in the promotion of sustainable or renewable energy, which is the function of the authority. Various fiscal measures are in place in other countries already and such measures need to be set out here because, for one reason or another, the traditional attitude of the Department of Finance has been that the purpose of taxation is to raise revenue and if taxation is ring fenced or gauged to alter behaviour by promoting an issue, for example, tax on cigarettes, the Department becomes uneasy. The authority must set out the arguments and the feasibility of fiscal measures to promote sustainable energy. For example, the UK has introduced a reduced VAT rate on renewable energy while Scandinavian countries and others have introduced a carbon tax to make sustainable energy economical by internalising the costs of the unsustainable energy. Those are important functions for the authority. Who will undertake such functions if the authority does not? The Minister of State should accept the principle of the amendments.
My amendment seeks that the authority should have a function is proposing fiscal or other measures to Government which would assist in the achievement of the authority's objectives. The other amendments are also worthy. I ask the Minister of State to give serious thought to them and to take on board the principle involved.
Comment on this
The first part of amendment No. 21 and amendment No. 31 suggest that the authority should be given the power to propose legislative and fiscal measures. It is strictly a matter for this or any Government to propose legislation and for the current or future Minister for Finance to propose fiscal measures. I cannot accept an amendment that provides otherwise. The role of the new authority on legislative or fiscal issues is to advise Ministers as appropriate and this is already a function of the authority as provided in section 6(1)(f).
Comment on this
The Minister of State is making the same mistake he made in the Seanad. My amendment does not state "initiate legislative measures". The Minister of State was corrected on this point in the Seanad. We are seeking that the authority be allowed to propose legislation to the Minister, not initiate it in the House. The amendment would strengthen section 6(1)(f).
Comment on this
The subsection states that it is a function of the authority "to provide advice, information and guidance to the Minister and such other Ministers or bodies as the Minister may direct".
Comment on this
We propose in that context that the function should include the proposal of legislative and-or fiscal measures to the Minister that might be required.
Comment on this
I accept that but we are trying to be more specific to give a clearer role to the authority and, thus, remove it from the civil servants sitting beside the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I refer to the second part of amendment No. 21 and amendment No. 26. The International Energy Agency and the EU produce a number of publications which compare energy policies of member states and in such circumstances we cannot duplicate their work. The Department already contributes to a number of EU fora which discuss energy statistics and relative indicators. One difficulty the authority faces is sourcing information in EU member states for comparison purposes. Due to different structural characteristics and climates, it is often difficult to make meaningful comparisons between countries on the relative success of sustainable energy measures. A plethora of studies and publications has been conducted and produced under the auspices of the IEA and the EU. I would hate to think of the level of resources that would be required by the authority to conduct studies of a substantial nature in this area. I cannot accept the amendments.
Comment on this
I do not accept the logic of the Minister of State's argument for non-publication of an annual report which would include a comparison with other countries. Contributing to international fora is fine but the Minister cannot argue that there is a plethora of statistics, reports and other documentation available and it would take too much time to go through them. There should be a small specialised unit within the new authority to evaluate what is happening in other member states and to update statistics regularly so that we can ascertain how our performance measures up to other countries. A number of EU member states have grabbed headlines and led the way and they are light years ahead of Ireland. An annual assessment should be made of our progress in comparison to other member states. The Minister of State's argument is not valid.