Sustainable Energy Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.
Contributions 129–257 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 27 of 2001 ›
I agree with the desirability of producing such information but the onus to do so should not be put on the new authority. Ireland already contributes to international fora and information should be compiled and be readily available with a view to availing of the innovations and progress in other countries. The suggestion is that this should be stitched into the legislation as a function of the authority and that is not on.
Comment on this
We are back to economics. The authority will be starved of resources so that it cannot draw comparisons with other countries. What is the Minister of State afraid of? What is being hidden? He should be brave and make a decision. He should talk to his officials and include these amendments.
Comment on this
We discussed real world stuff earlier. Deputy Stagg's terminology was "value for money". He argued that meant value for money. I do not know how we can get away from that if we are to live in the real world.
Comment on this
I do not doubt members of the authority will be exercised about and conscious of the financial and fiscal measures which would be needed and desirable to help promote sustainable energies and technologies. As matters stand, they need not bother their heads about it. They can be like inventors with their own private resources and dream up whatever they like as long as it is in line with the functions already laid down. The actual implementation of their innovations, which could be critically affected by fiscal measures, need not concern them.
Who will give the necessary thought and consideration to these matters outside the international forums, many of which are concerned with common positions such as a European wide eco-tax or some form of multi-lateral measure? The Minister of State said he did not want the agency poking its nose into the affairs of those outside Ireland. In that case it should be allowed devote itself to promoting sustainable energy in Ireland with all the means possible to do it, including giving advice, and not writing legislation or doing someone else's job.
There is a critical element associated with renewable energy, namely, the lack of fiscal measures. I have repeatedly asked the Minister for Finance in the Dáil about fiscal measures on this matter, I am told he is not convinced. Who will do the convincing? Other countries have been convinced, yet the Department of Finance remains to be convinced. This authority is best equipped to do that because it sees the need for sustainable energy and to convince the Minister of State's Department and, in turn, the Minister for Finance on this and it has the expertise to do so. Let its members use that expertise to bring about sustainable energy.
Comment on this
I would not disagree with anything the Deputy said. The Minister for Finance was sufficiently convinced for him to allocate substantial amounts of money to set up and fund this authority. The Deputy and others obviously convinced him.
Comment on this
I am not talking about the authority being set up. I am talking about the work it will do. People have not been convinced in this regard.
Comment on this
No. This is critical. This is not another add-on for the sake of having more to do. Fiscal measures will either create or prevent renewable energy coming into being and the Minister of State knows that.
Comment on this
It is provided for in the Bill and I pointed out where that is done. The legislation specifies that the authority should provide advice, information and guidance to the Minister, such other Ministers or bodies as the Minister may direct, and to energy suppliers and users relating to the matters specified in the paragraphs of this section. The track record of the Irish Energy Centre shows how efficient and competent it is and has been without this additional muscle, to use crude terminology, with which we are endeavouring to provide it.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said that the annual reports on the performance of the State relative to the other member states of the European Union in the matter of sustainable energy objectives should be made available and should be compiled and published. There is an opportunity in the legislation to give that role to the authority. If the Minister of State has decided not to give the role to the authority, who will do it?
Comment on this
The Minister of State, in reply to a question earlier from one of my colleagues, agreed that there was a need for the performance of the State relative to other EU member states in the matter of sustainable energy objectives to be compiled and made available. There is an opportunity in the Bill to give that role to the Sustainable Energy Authority because it is set up to deal with sustainable energy. The Minister of State said it should be done but that this authority should not do it. If it should be done, who will do it?
Comment on this
I am not talking about that. Who will compile the reports? It is a simple enough question.
Comment on this
Should this authority deem it requires this type of statistical information regarding innovative activities in other states, it will be made available.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said this authority will perform this task. Where is that stated in the Bill? I am seeking guidance, Chairman.
Comment on this
Section 6(2) states:
The Authority shall have all such powers as are necessary for or are incidental to the performance of its functions under this Act, including-
. . . (b) the compilation, extraction and dissemination of information and projections relating to energy production and use (including implications relating to the sourcing, transformation, transmission, distribution and emissions thereof);
I do not suppose I will need to explain the entire legislation. I am sure the Deputy has read it. Section 6(2)(i) refers to, “the exchange of information with organisations outside the State and participation in international activities”. It is included in the legislation.
Comment on this
I am grateful to the Minister of State for the clarity he has brought to this matter. Does this include comparisons between Ireland and other member states?
Comment on this
I would advise that this be done because it would be a productive and business-like way of doing things.
Comment on this
I must leave now. I have four remaining amendments in my name, Nos. 50, 53, 60 and 64. May I withdraw them now and table them for Report Stage?
Comment on this
On a similar matter, the Minister of State said we would be here until thecows come home. Unfortunately, the cows comehome for me about now. I wish to withdraw myamendments which have not yet been dealt with.
Comment on this
Those amendments will not be moved and will be treated similar to the amendments in the name of Deputy Stagg.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 22 to 24, inclusive, are out of order as they involve a potential charge on the Revenue.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 4, subsection (1), between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:
"(g) to prepare and publish annual reports on the performance of Government departments, agencies and local authorities in achieving energy efficient measures and targets.”.
State agencies and bodies are significant users of energy and need to begin to consider how they use energy, how efficiently they use it, how they save it and whether they use green energy. In response to a parliamentary question I was informed that such bodies do not use any green energy. The total energy requirement of State agencies is high. This amendment would give State agencies and local authorities the opportunity to take the lead as regards energy efficiency. I hope the Minister of State will take this issue on board.
Comment on this
We are back to the issue of resources. The consequences of accepting this amendment would be that the authority would need resources to audit each Department, agency and local authority on an annual basis. The Deputy's concerns, as expressed in the amendment, are adequately addressed by the reporting requirement as laid out in the Government's decision of 3 July 2001 that all Departments and State bodies be required to report to Government and to the Oireachtas in their annual reports on measures to reduce energy usage in buildings they occupy. This amendment would require the provision of resources well beyond those contemplated for the authority. It is part of the new authority's mandate to assist such bodies in meeting targets, establishing benchmarks and providing information. Publishing annual reports is an onerous task in terms of auditing and resources which, after all the work and expense, may not provide the desired results.
The Comptroller and Auditor General carries out value for money audits from time to time regarding areas of expenditure, including energy. The amendment is meritorious and has been given consideration. However, the Government's decision and its instruction to all Departments and State bodies to report annually on energy usage in their buildings are pertinent and necessary as regards our aspirations in the areas of energy efficiency and conservation.
Comment on this
I take the Minister of State's point. However, I am concerned that State bodies will report and that will be the end of the matter. This amendment seeks to ensure the authority would collate and analyse these reports and prepare an overall report. Reference was made to buildings. However, the Minister of State will know that many State agencies also use cars and other methods of transport which use a significant amount of energy, but this issue has not been mentioned. The agency might be given some role in assimilating and collating information from these State agencies and bodies and, perhaps, producing some overall strategy or advice on this matter. I would be happy to withdraw the amendment if the Minister of State will undertake to consider the matter before Report Stage.
Comment on this
We are discussing the issue of advice and the word "advice" appears throughout the legislation as a major function of the new authority. The amendment's proposal goes well beyond the authority's envisaged functions and requirements.
Comment on this
I accept the Minister of State's point, but will he consider expanding the authority's role a little so it would collate reports produced by State agencies? This would ensure the matter would not end with the presentation of reports, but the authority would collate the information and, perhaps, offer a general overall view as to the State's position in this regard. State agencies and bodies use a significant amount of energy and the State is perhaps the largest user of energy.
Comment on this
I am always loath to give a commitment to examine an issue and come back on Report Stage. I have stated as regards other issues that I will revert to them and that is a genuine commitment.
Comment on this
However, I do not intend to do so in this case as I do not see how the objective of the amendment is achievable, regardless of how desirable it may be in the context of the functions of the new authority.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has set his face against the objective of the amendment. I will withdraw the amendment, but reserve the right to table it again on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 4, subsection (2)(b), line 40, after “distribution” to insert “, conservation, efficiency”.
I am concerned that the word "conservation" does not appear in the Bill. The conservation of energy is important and we have tried on a number of occasions to insert the words "conservation" and "efficiency". This is the other side of the coin as regards the production of energy. We have to produce energy, but we must also conserve it and use it efficiently.
Section 2(b) refers to the compilation, extraction and dissemination of information and projections relating to energy production and use. It also lists issues such as transformation, transmission, distribution and emissions. The amendment proposes to include energy conservation and efficiency in this list. Will the Minister of State take on board this suggestion? It adds to the Bill at this stage.
Comment on this
The power under section 6(2)(b) relates to the new authority compiling benchmarks and statistics in relation to energy production and use and refers to the sourcing, transformation, transmission and distribution of and emissions from electricity. In a situation where the electricity market is liberalised and there are a number of electricity generators, the new authority will need to develop and provide statistics on emissions from all of these. In the past, this role would have been carried out by the ESB.
In the context of measuring the implications of such activity, conservation and efficiency are not readily measurable and it is considered that it would be impracticable. The authority has the power to measure, compile, extract and disseminate information in relation to energy efficiency and conservation by virtue of its functions as set out in subsection (1) of this section.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said that under subsection (1) the authority has the power to compile statistics in regard to conservation and efficiency. Perhaps he will assist me by showing me where that is.
Comment on this
The term "efficiency" - I use the word "conservation" quite a lot in that context - occurs throughout the Bill and is deemed to mean the same as "conservation".
Comment on this
Where in subsection (1) is there a function to compile statistics regarding conservation and efficiency in the use and production of energy? I cannot see this in subsection (1).
Comment on this
We are talking about the compilation, extraction and dissemination of information relating to the efficient use and conservation of energy.
Comment on this
Section 6(1)(b) states that the function of the authority shall be to promote and assist energy efficiency and renewable sources of energy. Section 6(2)(a) states:
The Authority shall have all such powers as are necessary for or are incidental to the performance of its functions under this Act, including
(a) co-operating with the Central Statistics Office and acting as an agent of that Office in relation to matters related to the functions of the Authority.
Comment on this
A number of amendments were ruled out of order. This is unfortunate, particularly in regard to amendments dealing with the transmission of energy, which is an important area. We are told, for instance, that if energy is transmitted through high voltage lines over long distances, quite an amount of it is lost. I would have thought it would have been useful for the authority to have functions in that regard, which is why we tabled the amendments.
We also tabled amendments relating to education as education is different from training and providing advice and guidance. It takes place in schools and universities and has not been mentioned in the Bill. I know there is advice in regard to the development of technologies. Education also deals with lifestyle and getting people to change their mindsets. Education, as such, has not been mentioned. Perhaps the Minister of State will look at this aspect at a later stage. The Irish Energy Centre is involved in education, including schools programmes and so on and I have seen some of the work it does on the world-wide web. It has produced nice material, including little thermometers and so on. However, it could do a lot more, not just by way of education in schools but by educating the general public too. Perhaps the Minister of State will consider an educative role for the authority.
The whole area of energy conservation and efficiency needs to be strengthened in the Bill. The use of energy conservation, including insulation, is very important. A number of years ago, people were trying to use paper as an insulating material. Every obstacle was put in the way of the company which eventually folded. We need to look at insulating buildings and how they are situated and designed. That is why energy conservation and efficiency was included.
I ask the Minister of State to note the points I have made.
Comment on this
I have absorbed the Deputy's comments. He spoke about the educational function of the authority, or the Irish Energy Centre as it currently stands. I agree the centre has a superb record in regard to the educational functions on which it embarks and have witnessed its personnel's performance in both first and second level schools. The programmes have been effective and efficient and their interaction with pupils of all ages in conveying the message of energy conservation and efficiency has been superb. Education at the level on which the centre has embarked in the past has been superbly executed and very effective. The management and staff of the centre deserve our compliments and congratulations on their work.
The amendment relating to the wider education people may have envisaged was disallowed because it impinged on the Exchequer. However, I take the very valid points made by the Deputy.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 5, before section 7, to insert the following new section:
"7.-(1) The Authority may, with the consent of the Minister and the Minister for Finance, perform any of its functions through a subsidiary and, for the purpose of such performance, may acquire, form or establish one or more than one subsidiaries (within the meaning of section 155 of the Companies Act 1963) and for that purpose may acquire, hold or dispose of shares or any other interest in a company or become a member of a company (within the meaning of the Companies Acts 1963 to 2001).
(2) In relation to the exercise of its powers under subsection (1)-
(a) the Board of the Authority shall ensure that the memorandum and articles of association of a subsidiary are in a form consistent with this Act, and that the prior approval of the Minister and the Minister for Finance are obtained in relation to such memorandum and articles, and any alterations to them;
(b) the Minister may give a direction in writing to the Authority on any matter relating to a subsidiary, and the Authority shall comply or ensure compliance with any such direction;
(c) the Minister shall not issue a direction to the Authority under paragraph (b) which relates to the disposal of any assets or surpluses of a subsidiary without the consent of the Minister for Finance;
(d) the grades of staff and the number of staff of a subsidiary shall be determined by the Board of the Authority, with the consent of the Minister and the Minister for Finance;
(e) the staff of any subsidiary shall hold office or employment subject to such terms and conditions as are approved by the Minister with the consent of the Minister for Finance.”.
The amendment provides for the authority to have the power to establish subsidiaries in order for some of its functions to be performed through such subsidiaries, if it so desires. I believe it to be a valuable instrument for the authority in the exercise of its functions. It could allow it establish subsidiaries that could, for example, support the development of new services in the marketplace and realise the value of intellectual property accruing from research expenditure, and establish a new activity of a regulatory certification or data holding kind where there is a formal need to establish it on a stand-alone basis because of possible conflicts of interest with promotional activity. Trading and verification schemes are possible examples. While the current centre has no immediate plans to establish subsidiaries upon its establishment as the new authority, this section will allow it the freedom to delegate functions as the need arises in future, subject to the agreement of the Minister and, of course, the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 35 and 39 may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 5, subsection (1), lines 27 and 28, to delete "the production, supply (including security of supply) and use of energy" and substitute "sustainable energy, energy efficiency and renewable energy".
This section currently provides for the possible assignment of additional functions related to the production, supply, including security of supply, and use of energy. After further consultation with interested parties, including the Commission for Electricity Regulation, concern was expressed that such a precise reference to security of supply in this Bill would be likely to lead to legislative confusion, in so far as the mandates of the CER and the new authority are concerned. This would be primarily because the CER accepts it is accountable for ensuring the security of Ireland's electricity supply, as mandated in section 9(4)(b) of the Electricity Regulation Act, 1999. This section imposes a duty on the CER to have regard to the need to ensure that all reasonable demands by final customers of electricity are met and to promote the continuity, security and quality of supplies of electricity.
I am, therefore, proposing these amendments which will limit the scope of possible additional functions that can be given to the authority to functions that relate to sustainable energy, energy efficiency and renewable energy. It was considered that the current wording of this provision is too wide in scope, referring to energy in the widest sense. The new authority has a huge job of work to do over the next number of years as climate change issues grow and I am anxious to ensure the authority retains its focus and directs its resources to the vital area of promotion of sustainable energy, energy efficiency and renewable energy.
Additional functions could arise from the implementation of EU directives, regulations and policy in the energy efficiency, renewable energy and sustainable energy area or the Minister may wish to transfer functions relating to energy from existing agencies or bodies to the new authority. This may be done only following consultation with the authority, the Minister for Finance and any other Minister who would be concerned with such an assignment.
The assignment of additional functions to the authority by the Minister can be done only by positive statutory order and Deputies will note that under section 8, any such order must first be approved by both Houses of the Oireachtas before being made by the Minister, thereby giving the Oireachtas a say in any function to be transferred or given to the authority under this section.
Comment on this
I agree with what the Minister has said. It makes sense and was something I was going to raise because I was curious about the security of supply aspect.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 5, subsection (1), line 29, after "appropriate" to insert "in accordance with the energy sustainability objectives of section 6”.
This amendment was tabled to strengthen the section but the Minister of State's amendments have strengthened it. I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 5, subsection (2), lines 32 and 33, to delete "the production, supply (including security of supply) and use of energy" and substitute "sustainable energy, energy efficiency and renewable energy".
Comment on this
I have no major difficulty with this section except that the area of insulation, conservation and so on could be strengthened. My amendments have been ruled out of order but I may introduce them in different ways on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 6, subsection (1), line 3, after "members" to insert "at least one of whom shall be elected by the employees of the Authority".
When this matter arose during the debate on another Bill the Minister for Public Enterprise agreed that it was important the staff of an agency or authority be represented on the board of the agency or authority. This amendment would allow staff to elect a representative to the board. The Minister strongly agreed with the need for such a provision when we debated the Transport (Railway Infrastructure) Bill. Because the Minister established a precedent in the previous Bill we thought it useful to continue the practice here. It was felt at the time to be a good practice and I hope the Minister of State will follow the practice of the Minister for Public Enterprise.
Comment on this
It is Government policy that the appointment of worker directors to commercial State bodies is needed. This is provided for under the worker participation Acts. It is not Government policy to provide for staff to appoint a member to the boards of non-commercial bodies. There appears to be legislative provision for this in a limited number of cases only. What has become custom and practice for such companies is the appointment of a representative to the board from the trade union pillar of the social partnership.
The new authority is, of necessity, going to be a small State body with, perhaps, no more than 50 staff. Sub-board structures can be implemented to ensure adequate information flows to the staff and the authority would be failing in its duty if it did not provide for proper communication channels to the staff.
I undertake to appoint a representative of the trade union pillar of the social partnership to the board.
Comment on this
I am amazed at this. During discussions on previous legislation is was clear that the Minister for Public Enterprise was happy with this proposal. It is important that employees be represented on boards. I will revisit this matter on Report Stage and I reserve the right to move an amendment then. In the meantime, the Minister of State might consult his senior colleague to see if there is some way whereby employees can be represented.
It is possible that this authority will grow in size and increase its functions, importance and responsibilities. It is a good precedent that employees be represented on the board and to tell the board directly what is happening on the ground. While it is a good idea to have a representative of the trade union pillar, that is not the same as having an employee, like a worker-director, on the board's agency in accordance with good practice. We all agree on the need for whistle-blower legislation and a worker-director on the board would help in this regard. I ask the Minister to look at this again.
Comment on this
I will be happy to discuss this issue again on Report Stage in light of what the Deputy said about the rail procurement agency with which I want to make myself au fait.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:
In page 6, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) The members of the Board shall direct and carry out the functions of the Authority in accordance with this Act and shall satisfy themselves as to the adequacy of the systems in place for that purpose and shall otherwise manage and review the workings of the Authority.".
We are trying to expand the board's functions in this amendment. Such a provision is found in many pieces of legislation and should not be a problem here. Perhaps the Minister will accept the amendment.
Comment on this
This amendment covers in general terms what is in the Department of Finance's new code of practice for the governance of State bodies. Due to the existence of this code, it was not the intention to include anything on this matter in the Bill. One of my concerns is that the amendment refers to the board managing the workings of the authority as that is the role of the chief executive under his contract of employment. My previous career was at managerial level in the State sector before moving into this lifestyle and, because of that, I am anxious to avoid the board's having a statutory duty to manage the authority. However, we will look at it again and return to it on Report Stage in light of Deputy Stanton's comments.
Comment on this
I accept what the Minister said, but this provision is found in other legislation and we must outline what the board does. I will withdraw the amendment in light of the Minister's undertaking to examine it again.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
In page 6, between lines 3 and 4, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) The Minister, with the consent of the Minister of Finance, shall nominate people to be members of the Board and each person so nominated, on accepting the nomination, and prior to appointment to the Board by the Minister shall appear before a Committee of Dáil Éireann established under the Standing Orders of Dáil Éireann in order to answer questions regarding his or her suitability, qualifications and experience and the Minister shall not appoint a member without prior approval of the said Dáil Committee.".
This is a crucial amendment which brings into the public domain the nomination and appointment of members of boards of State bodies. Although one or two people should not have been appointed to certain boards, many excellent people are appointed to boards of State bodies and do great work, yet the public, for the most part, does not know anything about them. In other jurisdictions, people appointed to such bodies present themselves before a committee of Parliament to answer a few questions. This is done in public with the media present and people can view the official record afterwards. I am not suggesting that matters are not above board as they are conducted now, but this process would be open and transparent. This amendment seeks to have nominated people appear before an appropriate Oireachtas committee to answer committee members' questions prior to their appointment by the Minister. Unless something arose in the proceedings to cast doubt over a person's suitability, the committee would approve the nomination.
I recognise that this is a groundbreaking amendment, and that something similar has only been proposed in a few cases, but it would establish a good precedent. I ask the Minister to consider it seriously and, as we are establishing a new authority with a new name, we should allow the board's members, who will undoubtedly be people of the highest calibre, to come before this committee to explain what they have to offer and what benefit they will be. This is new and positive. If the Minister does not accept it now, perhaps he will consider it on Report Stage. The public would be happy to see politicians opening State boards to such scrutiny.
Comment on this
There would be many committee meetings when the next Government fills all the boards.
Comment on this
This amendment is without precedent regarding the appointment of members to a State body. It would be unique in our system. Many people, who would be eminent board members, might not be prepared to submit to questioning about their suitability or qualifications.
Comment on this
This proposal would make it difficult to get sufficient suitable people to sit on the board. The suggested mechanism would also be a problem given the volume involved. There may be another forum or device by which such an innovative idea might be introduced, but it has no place in this Bill. I do not accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I did not think the Minister would. He cited volume as a reason for rejecting it, but the board members only change every ten years. He also said that people would not be prepared to appear before this committee, but that should not be so as we would like to meet board members who are appointed by the State and do good work on its behalf. Why should this not be in the open with the public and the media allowed to see who is appointed to State boards? It would give these people a chance to outline their background and qualifications are and their reasons for wanting to serve the State. There is a great clamour for board membership when the process is not open and transparent, so why should there not be when it is? If we had hearings, people would still be anxious to serve. I do not wish to press the Minister on this, but put it down as a marker of the manner in which I would like to see these boards conducted.
Comment on this
We all know there are eminent, excellent people serving on our State boards who do not do so for financial gain as it is not a profitable exercise. We are fortunate to have these patriotic people who are prepared to give of their experience and expertise. I do not suggest these people would want to be anything other than open and transparent but they treasure their privacy and, while willing to serve their country on a State board, might be reluctant about this proposal.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In page 6, line 6, before ",and" to insert "as soon as may be after the establishment day".
At this stage, I will be happy whether or not the Minister accepts the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 6, between lines 11 and 12, to insert the following subsection:
"(4) Each member of the Authority shall be a person who, in the opinion of the Minister, has wide experience and competence in relation to one or more of the following areas:
(a) renewable energy methodologies and technologies,
(b) conservation and efficient use of energy,
(c) environmental matters,
(d) education,
(e) engineering,
(f) economics,
(g) finance,
(h) the construction industry,
(i) urban development,
(j) energy production and supply,
(k) motor engineering,
(l) legal matters.".
This follows on the previous amendment concerning State boards. It seeks to ensure that the members of the authority will have experience and something tangible to offer and that each appointed member will have one or more of these competencies. In putting a board together, it would be useful to have some member with expertise in renewable energy methodologies and technologies or in conservation and efficient use of energy. I know the Minister has a problem with the word "conservation" but we can remove that and leave it as efficient use of energy. It would be desirable that members would have some experience or knowledge of environmental matters. We mentioned education earlier, not just education in schools but broad-based community education. Engineering would be a desirable area of experience for at least one member of the board. The Minister himself mentioned economics as an area of expertise and finance is related to that. The construction industry is a huge user of energy both at construction stage and later in the use of energy by the constructed buildings. Urban development is related as houses are built where energy is needed all day. Energy production and supply, motor engineering and legal matters are also areas where it would be desirable to have some person with experience on the board.
This expertise would make for a board that was competent, professional and wide-ranging in experience. Every member of the board should have at least one area of competence. In the future, any Minister appointing a member to this authority should have to take account of these requirements. The Minister may wish to add or delete some areas. This amendment is a positive one which shows we are serious.
Comment on this
In appointing members to the board, it is natural that the Minister and the Minister for Finance seek people with experience and competence in areas relevant to the work of the authority. I decided against including a list of relevant experience or competencies on the grounds that they could be restrictive. Certain competencies or experience could be overlooked or, due to development, new competencies could become relevant. I agree with the Deputy's list of desirable areas of experience and expertise and we are fortunate that the members of the interim board are competent in these areas. However, issues may arise in the future which we have not anticipated. We see entrepreneurs, with no apparent background or identifiable expertise in a particular area coming forward every day and doing great things. Let us not limit that. I am not opposed in principle to such a list. I will take more time to consider it and will come back to the matter on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 6, subsection (5), line 15, to delete "monies" and substitute "moneys".
This is a drafting amendment. The amendment proposes to align the spelling with that more commonly used in legislation.
Comment on this
It is approaching 5.30 p.m. and we have been here for three hours. Next week, we will have the Meteorological Protection Bill to complete and there are very few amendments on it. Does the committee wish to take the remainder of this Bill next week with that?
The Select Committee went into private session at 5.28 p.m. and resumed in public session at5.29 p.m.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 48 and 49 form a composite proposal and will be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In page 6, lines 36 to 37, to delete subsection (10) and substitute the following:
"10) (a) A member of the Board shall not be eligible for reappointment if he or she has served two consecutive terms as a member of the Board.
(b) the Minister, when appointing members of the Board (other than the Chief Executive), shall fix such members, term of membership which shall not exceed five years.”.
In the Bill, as drafted, a member of the board shall not serve more than ten consecutive years. We are anxious to ensure a review takes place after five years. I know there are roll over mechanisms in the Bill. We proposed this in the Railway Procurement Agency Bill and the Minister thought it was a good idea and incorporated it in the legislation. The membership should be for five years, but a member can serve two consecutive terms. There would be a possibility of reappointment after five years if things are going well. It does not greatly change the Bill's intent, but it gives the Minister of the day the opportunity after five years to review the membership of the authority and to make changes, if necessary. The Minister felt ten years in the Railway Procurement Agency Bill was a long time for one person to be on a board. This gives the Minister the opportunity to review it after five years. I ask the Minister of State to follow the Minister's precedent in the legislation.
Comment on this
In framing the Bill's provisions relating to the period of service of board members, I sought to ensure some continuity while, at the same time, allowing for change and new blood on the board. I have also allowed for the possibility of reappointing board members if the Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, feels the board would benefit from further service by that member. The provisions of subsections (7), (8), (9) and (10) are a package designed to meet the objective of continuity and change at the same time. Any change to that package, such as limiting the period a member of the board can serve, could render the provisions of these subsections inoperable. I would be disinclined, therefore, to alter the package because of the way the elements are interrelated to bring about the desired result. The proposed amendments are too constraining. The proposal in the Bill will give us the opportunity to change the board after three years. We also have the possibility of changing three members in the fourth, fifth and sixth years. There can be a full change within that time or the expertise we mentioned can be retained. I am sure we will have good people. There is flexibility to get new blood depending on the individuals' circumstances, but there is also the possibility of achieving the continuity to which we aspire. I would like to keep it as a package.
Comment on this
I am aware that is included. I will withdraw the amendment on the basis of what the Minister of State said.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:
In page 7, subsection (13), lines 5 and 6, to delete ", in the Minister's opinion,".
The phrase, "in the Minister's opinion", is too subjective. It would be better if the member was incapable through ill health. The subsection allows the Minister to remove a member of the board if he or she is incapable through ill health or has committed stated misbehaviour. That should be proven; it should not be subject to the Minister's opinion. Ill health and stated misbehaviour are clear reasons. We want to delete the phrase, "in the Minister's opinion", because it is too subjective.
Comment on this
I am reminded of the discussion on Second Stage in the Seanad when I put forward the view that it is important to retain the current wording for a number of reasons. The step proposed is a serious one which is necessary if a member of the board becomes incapacitated. Before a Minister removes a member of the board he or she must form an opinion that the board member is ill or otherwise unable to fulfil his or her duties. Any Minister taking such a course of action must seek advice and consult the appropriate people in advance, including medical people if health issues are involved. If, however, the individual removed from the board feels it was done unreasonably by the Minister, he or she has recourse to question the decision through a judicial review. That is only right and proper and should alleviate the concern that the provision would be open to abuse. Colleagues will also be aware that the provision in question is standard in many Acts setting up bodies to which appointments are made, including one brought forward by my Department, the Aviation Regulation Act, 2001, the Industrial Development (Enterprise Ireland) Act, 1998, the Comhairle Act, 2000, and the Irish Sports Council Act, 1999. I am not inclined to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I probably agree with the Minister of State. If a person was removed by a Minister and the reason was not ill health or stated misbehaviour, the Minister could possibly be challenged by the person. The phrase, "in the Minister's opinion", is subjective. We are concerned that the Minister could decide to remove a person from the board if he or she believes the person is not well enough to do the job. I accept what the Minister of State said and I withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52:
In page 7, subsection (14), line 10, after "Board" to insert "other than the Chief Executive".
I propose to insert the words, "other than the Chief Executive", after the "Board" as this subsection must exclude the chief executive who is not appointed by the Minister. The chief executive is appointed by the board and is an ex officio member of the board. As the chief executive leaves the board by virtue of leaving his post as chief executive, there will not be a casual vacancy to be filled.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
In page 7, subsection (1), line 37, after "functions" to insert "but shall hold at least one meeting in each quarter of the calendar year".
This is a technical amendment to require the board to have at least one meeting in each quarter of the calendar year. Perhaps it would have a certain number of meetings per year. This requirement is found in other legislation. I am not sure if it is required, but perhaps the Minister of State might advise us in that regard.
Comment on this
The interim board which we appointed in December 2000 to oversee the transition of the centre to the new authority has met on a monthly basis since then, which is what it deemed necessary to properly execute its functions. While recognising the safeguard the amendment provides, I will impress on the chairman of the new authority that I expect board meetings to be held more frequently than that specified in the proposal. I consider the provision to be the minimum required for the proper execution of its functions. I am prepared to accept the amendment which provides for at least one meeting in each quarter of the calendar year.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In page 9, subsection (8), line 24, after "Authority" to insert "and shall be responsible to the Board for the performance of his or her functions and for the implementation of the policies of the Authority".
This is a technical amendment which seeks to expand the role of the authority. It would serve better to define its role.
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to define the responsibility of the chief executive to the board. Its thrust is clearly implied in the Bill. The board appoints the chief executive who will have a contract of employment from it. That contract will clearly set out his or her duties and responsibilities. We are trying to provide in law for operational matters of the authority, something we discussed earlier this afternoon. We are appointing a board to do certain things and I believe strongly that we should let it get on with them. I do not know how strongly Deputy Stanton feels about the matter.
Comment on this
I take what the Minister of State says, that generally the chief executive will be responsible to the board for the performance of his or her functions - the board appoints him or her in the first place - and the implementation of the policies of the authority. All the amendment seeks to do is state that it would strengthen the relationship between the board and the chief executive. Without formally pressing it, I would be inclined to ask the Minister of State to accept it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56:
In page 9, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following subsection:
"(9) Such functions of the Chief Executive as from time to time may be specified by him or her may, with the consent of the Board, be performed by such member of the staff of the Authority as may be authorised by the Chief Executive.".
This is a standard amendment where the chief executive is away from time to time and can delegate. It may not be necessary, but perhaps the Minister of State would inform us of his advise on the matter.
Comment on this
The amendment is covered by section 15(5). The requirement for the consent of the board could constrain the effective operation of the authority. It is clearly the chief executive's job to ensure the functions of the authority and the chief executive are carried out properly and adequately. He or she must make all necessary arrangements.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:
In page 9, between lines 28 and 29, to insert the following subsection:
"(10) The functions of the Chief Executive may be performed in his or her absence or when the position of the Chief Executive is vacant by such a member of the staff of the Authority as may from time to time be designated for that purpose by the Board.".
This amendment would cover a situation where the chief executive is absent or ill, in order that somebody else might be appointed to take over his or her role in the interim. It is a standard provision in many Bills, although I do not see it in this one. It would be useful to specifically insert it.
Comment on this
I am sure this amendment is well intended. This type of situation occurs under good governance requirements and contracts of employment. As I said concerning the previous amendment, perhaps we should not legislate for it. The amendment may constrain good practice.
Comment on this
Many pieces of legislation have provided for this particular requirement that when the chief executive is absent somebody else can be designated to take over his or her role. I do not know whether it is required to be included under statute, but by inserting it it would ensure the board could appoint somebody in the interim to take over the functions of the chief executive. Can the board do so if it is not provided for in the legislation? That is the question that arises. Perhaps it can, but it would be amazing if the board came back to us at a later stage to state, "The chief executive is sick and we cannot appoint anyone to take his or her place because we do not have the power to do so." That is what the amendment is about, although perhaps it is already covered in the legislation. I do not know.
Comment on this
I will give the matter further consideration and provide clarification on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:
In page 10, subsection (6)(c), line 13, to delete “section 19 of” and substitute “Part XIII of the Second Schedule to”.
This amendment is moved to maintain consistency with section 13(c) which excludes a member of the board from membership of the European Parliament. While section 19 of the European Parliament (Elections) Act, 1997, does refer to the filling of casual vacancies, these vacancies will be filled in accordance with Part XIII of the Second Schedule to the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 11, subsection (7), line 13, to delete "member of staff or Chief Executive" and substitute "person".
This amendment is necessary in order to more accurately reflect the reference to section 15(1), in which there is no reference to the chief executive officer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:
In page 12, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following subsection:
"(7) The Chief Executive, a member of the Board, a member of the staff of the Authority, or a consultant, advisor or person engaged by the Authority shall notify the Board of a potential conflict of interest or circumstance in which the person has a doubt about a conflict of interest and shall desist from pursuing an interest that they know to be in conflict with the working of the Authority.".
This amendment concerns conflicts of interest. I have come across a similar provision in other legislation. It may already be covered in the Bill, but I have moved the amendment in case it is not. The amendment concerns a situation where a person may have a doubt about a conflict of interest. He or she may be doing work he or she knows is in conflict with the work of the authority. He or she will, therefore, have to let the authority know he or she is doing so and desist from it. As this is an energy Bill, people may be involved in particular areas that could be in conflict. Perhaps the Minister of State will comment on the matter.
Comment on this
The concern behind the amendment is already covered to a large extent by the existing text. In addition, the new code of practice for the governance of State bodies provides that all State bodies should have written codes of business conduct for directors and employees. Appendix B of the Department of Finance's code contains the framework for a code of business conduct. One of the items it embraces is the issue of conflicts of interest.
The proposed amendment is far too broad. I am concerned about the reference to a "potential conflict of interest" which goes beyond the norm, which is simply to refer to a conflict of interest. Either there is a conflict of interest or there is not. If a person has any doubt in regard to a conflict of interest, then he or she is required to do something about it, both under the existing provisions and the code of business conduct.
The last part of the amendment appears to be something of a blunt instrument. A person faced with a conflict of interest should be given a choice of continuing to work with the authority and giving up his or her other interest, or leaving it and continuing with his or her other interest. The legislation adequately covers any fears or reservations we might have with regard to a conflict of interest. I am not inclined to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment at this stage. I saw it in some other legislation and felt it might be useful. It has appeared in other legislation and it is curious that the Minister called it a blunt instrument, but I take his point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:
In page 13, subsection (2), line 3, to delete "(£1,575.13)".
This is an amendment to delete the Irish pound figure from section 18 in line with the policy in all Bills to be enacted after 1 January 2002 which should only contain the euro figure.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 14, subsection (1), line 21, to delete "six" and substitute "two".
I felt six months was a long time for the Minister to have the annual report before laying it before the Houses of the Oireachtas and that two months would be better. Maybe there is a reason for deciding on six months but perhaps two months would be more appropriate.
Comment on this
Recently-enacted legislation establishing State bodies provides for six months, as is the case with the Comhairle Act, 2000. The six month period for publishing reports and accounts is also consistent with the recently published code of practice for State bodies by the Department of Finance which allows State bodies up to six months to submit their annual reports and accounts. The accounts of the authority will be audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General. It would be impractical for his office to meet the tight deadline required by this proposed amendment. Needless to say, the authority will be anxious to publish its annual report with all haste. To shorten the period in which the new authority will be required to submit its annual report would be impractical and I am loath, therefore, to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I am enlightened by the Minister's reply. I thought the Minister would have the report after six months but it seems the time between the Minister receiving the report and its production are included in the six months.
Comment on this
The Minister must lay the report before the Houses of the Oireachtas within six months but within that time, the authority must submit the report. There is no particular time scale for that. Am I right in saying it could submit the report to the Minister five months after the end of the financial year but that the Minister must then, by law, submit it within a month?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 15, between lines 19 and 20, to insert the following subsection:
"(6) The Minister shall make information on the finances and operation of the agency available to Dáil Members in response to Parliamentary Questions and the Authority shall co-operate in the matter when requested to do so by the Minister.".
This matter came up in previous legislation. On Second Stage of this and other legislation, many colleagues voiced concern in regard to the difficulty in obtaining information from State bodies. Even by way of parliamentary question, we are often told the Minister has no responsibility to the Dáil in regard to a matter. The public is perplexed by this. If elected Members of Parliament stands up in the Dáil and asks the Minister under whose remit the State body operates for information regarding the workings of the body, they are told they cannot get it. The Member will write to or will contact the body only to be told it is not obliged to tell him or her anything. There is a problem of democratic accountability.
Basically what this amendment proposes is that the Minister would make information on the finances and operation of the agency available to all Members in response to parliamentary questions and that the authority shall co-operate in the matter when requested to do so by the Minister. We are not saying the Minister should be responsible to the Dáil for the operation of the agency but should make information available. This is something that should be done. This would be useful in respect of many State bodies. The Minister could look for information in the same way as a Minister could look for information from health boards and Iarnród Éireann. The Minister, Deputy O'Rourke, has been doing that very well in her office and has brought forward information even though she does not really have to do so.
This amendment means that in the operation of this authority, the Minister would be able to make information available to Members of the House by way parliamentary question and that the authority would co-operate when asked to do so by the Minister. It is something I would like to see explored as far as all State bodies are concerned. Maybe the Minister will take the opportunity to allow it to happen here.
Comment on this
I suppose all of us at one time or other have experienced frustration at being told by Ministers that something was not a matter for them but for the State board. We have all felt that frustration. However, under Dáil Standing Orders, parliamentary questions may be put to the Minister in relation to Government policy as regards any State under his or her aegis. I do not think we can approach this in a piecemeal manner and endeavour to cure it, be it a very desirable innovation. If there is to be change in this regard, it should be more appropriately made to Standing Orders than by including it in the legislation which I would consider to be more or less in a piecemeal fashion.
Comment on this
This section provides that the authority has the power to accept subscriptions and donations, subject to the approval of the Minister. Are other State bodies allowed to do this?
Comment on this
The Irish Energy Centre doesnot have the power to receive subscriptionsbut it will be important for the authority to do so as it develops its networks. For example, it may wish to put the self-audit group or companies in the boiler programme on a membership basis. At present the centre receives sponsorship from time to time on specific activities or products. An example is sponsorship received for products produced for Energy Awareness Week or contributions towards the cost of producing school books on energy efficiency.
Comment on this
I thank you, Chairman, your predecessor in the Chair and your officials for taking this important legislation today. I also thank Deputy Stanton, his colleagues and my officials for their excellent work. The committee has improved the legislation and I look forward to Report and Final Stages.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and his officials for facilitating some of our amendments and for agreeing to consider others. We look forward to further robust debate on Report Stage. This is important legislation and we have treated it as such, having considered the Bill section by section. I thank the Chairman and his officials for their patience.